Cantonese 先 (sin1): first goes at the end

English puts first in front of the verb, and so does Mandarin. Cantonese hangs 先 sin1 on the end of the whole verb phrase, which is one of the clearest differences between the two spoken languages.

The short versionSay the action, then close it with 先: 我食飯先, let me eat first. 你行先 is you go ahead. Mandarin says 我先走 with the word in front; Cantonese says 我行先 with it at the end. The 先至 that means only then is a different word job.

先 closes the phrase

Everything else in the sentence finishes first. The verb, the object, all of it lands, and then 先 goes on the end to say this one comes before whatever else is coming. It is the position that carries the meaning, not the word itself.

ngo5 sik6 faan6 sin1
Let me eat first
先 after the object
nei5 haang4 sin1
You go ahead
the everyday way to let someone pass
ngo5 cung1 loeng4 sin1
I am going to shower first
verb phrase, then 先
The Mandarin split

This is a real difference rather than a matter of style. Mandarin puts the word before the verb, 我先走. Cantonese puts it after the verb phrase, 我行先. Anyone arriving from Mandarin produces 我先行 for months before the habit shifts, and it is one of the fastest things to fix because the rule has no exceptions worth worrying about.

Not the 先 in 先至

先至 sin1 zi3 means only then. It sits in front of the verb in the second half of a sentence and waits on a condition: 食完飯先至去, not going until the meal is finished. That is about one thing depending on another, and it has its own page. The 先 here is about order alone: this one now, the rest after.

ngo5 zou6 jyun4 sin1
我做完先
Let me finish first
先 still closes the phrase

Where you will actually hear it

先 turns up constantly in ordinary politeness. Letting someone through a door is 你行先. Excusing yourself from a table is 我食飯先. Asking for a moment before you answer is 我諗吓先. It also softens an instruction, which is why it sits comfortably alongside the patterns on the requests page.

Common mistakes

Fronting it

我先食飯 is the Mandarin order. Spoken Cantonese closes the phrase instead: 我食飯先.

Confusing it with 先至

先 on the end orders two things. 先至 in front says the second one will not happen until the first does. Different jobs, different slots.

Adding a particle after it

先 is already closing the sentence. 我食飯先啦 is heard, but a bare 我食飯先 is the neutral form to learn first.

Continue reading on the blog